Part two: A super split does not divide the paddockBY TROY ARMSTRONG | FRIDAY, 6 NOV 2026 8:40AMPart one of this thought piece discussed why splitting superannuation evenly in family law settlements does not always create a fair outcome in practice, potentially leading to serious financial problems for farming families, particularly when an SMSF owns farmland and related assets. Part two highlights the practical and legal complications that arise after a farming SMSF is split during a separation. The deadlock There's a simpler problem to raise before any of that. A fund with two individual trustees usually can't act until both sign, and when those two are the separating couple, the fund can sit still for months. I've watched funds sit still for a season while the lease, the tax position, and the operation all needed decisions made. None of it appears in the settlement documents and all of it turns up afterwards. A corporate trustee gives you more room, depending on what the constitution says, which is a good argument for reading it early rather than in the middle of an argument. The room The changes to the Family Law Act that took effect on 10 June 2025 have had fourteen months to settle in, and they ask the court to weigh matters including the nature and extent of each party's liabilities and any wastage of property. On a farm, debt is structural and seasonal rather than something run up on a credit card. The overdraft swells before harvest and drains after it, and a balance sheet caught at the wrong month reads like trouble when it's really just the calendar. That distinction needs explaining to whoever's doing the weighing, and explaining it properly takes someone who can read the thing. Mediation usually leaves a family more room here than a courtroom does, and not only because it's calmer and cheaper, although it's normally both. In a mediation you can design the composition of each side's share. Court orders tend to land on percentages, which are exactly where this comes unstuck. There's an obvious objection, which is that a family's long-standing adviser isn't a neutral party and the other side's lawyer will say so. That's fair enough, and it's the reason the adviser's contribution should be about composition and consequence, what each parcel does, what it costs to move, and what income it produces, rather than about who deserves what. Both parties can bring an adviser of their own. What matters is that somebody in the room can read the fund. What this means The lawyers handle the mechanism, whether that's consent orders or a binding financial agreement, and each party needs their own independent legal advice because that's their work and it should be. Mine is narrower. It's making sure when the split is done, the person left holding a share of the fund can live off it without having to sell the place to do it, and that what's left is still whole enough to hand to the next generation. A settlement can be even to the dollar and fail both of those tests. The tax bill that follows won't be a surprise to anyone who looked, and it will be a very large surprise to everyone who didn't. That's the That's the part I'd want a family thinking about before the numbers are agreed, rather than after. Your land. Your legacy. Looked after. |
Latest News
Australia's family offices surpass $323bn in assets
Mining, property fuel Aussie billionaires' wealth
HNWIs demand outperforming, mission-driven endowment funds
Family businesses turn to external chief executives: Deloitte
Cover Story

Generation next
FINANCE DIRECTOR
GOWING BROS LTD








